Skip to content
Cart

Bicycle Blue Book vs. The Pro's Closet: Who's More Legit?

TPC and Bicycle Blue Book are competitors in the used bike market. When it comes to buying a used bike, we each have pros and cons. Let's take a look at what we do well and what Bicycle Blue Book does better.

Written by: TPC

Published on:

Posted in:FAQs

When shopping for used bikes, two platforms stand out: The Pro's Closet (that’s us) and Bicycle Blue Book. Each offers unique services and benefits that suit the needs and preferences of both enthusiasts and casual riders. Here's a detailed look at what each platform offers, helping you decide the best fit for you on your used bike buying journey.

[button]Shop Bikes[/button]

What is The Pro's Closet

At TPC we’ve carved a niche in the market with a focus on high-quality, Certified Pre-Owned bikes. While we cater to cyclists of all levels, our inventory lean heavily toward performance road, gravel, and mountain bikes, and exclude many older models. These tend to appeal to more discerning or experienced riders, but they are great for any rider interested in looking beyond entry-level bikes. Our team of professional bike mechanics meticulously inspects and services every Certified Pre-Owned ensuring they are always safe and ready-to-ride. The Pro's Closet also carries more than bikes. We offer a wide range of components, accessories, and apparel.

What is Bicycle Blue Book

Bicycle Blue Book positions itself as an authoritative source for bike valuation, offering a comprehensive database to determine the fair market value of used bikes. Their platform facilitates buying, selling, and trading bicycles, with a broader focus that includes a variety of bikes of varying ages and condition. While it might not offer the same level of inspection and certification as TPC, Bicycle Blue Book provides a vital service for those seeking to understand the value of their bikes or find a deal in the used bike market.

TPC vs. BBB Comparison: Pros and Cons

  • Inventory and quality: TPC's curated selection of premium, Certified Pre-Owned bikes while Bicycle Blue Book has a broader, more inclusive inventory.
  • Bike valuation tools: TPC will make offers to buy high-quality used bikes that fits our Certified Pre-Owned criteria.  Bicycle Blue Book offers an expansive valuation tool that helps users estimate the market value of any bike.
  • User experience: TPC provides detailed information and photography documenting bike condition. We also have expert Ride Guides who can be contacted via phone, email, or chat to answer questions about bikes and help riders purchase the right gear for their cycling needs. Bicycle Blue Book serves as an easy-to-use resource for market research.

Users praise TPC for its quality assurance and customer service but note the premium pricing. On the other hand, Bicycle Blue Book is commended for its valuable pricing information and market breadth, though some users wish for more detail on individual bike conditions.

Choosing between The Pro's Closet and Bicycle Blue Book should align with your priorities. If inspection, service, and high-quality premium bikes are your focus, TPC is the way to go. However, if you're seeking a broad understanding of the used bike market or want to explore a more extensive inventory, Bicycle Blue Book could be your go-to resource.

The Pro's Closet

Pros: High-quality bikes, rigorous inspection and service of Certified Pre-Owned bikes, and comprehensive product information.

Cons: Higher price points, selection tends to favor newer and performance models.

Bicycle Blue Book

Pros: Extensive valuation database, broader inventory, offers bikes in a wide range of conditions.

Cons: Less emphasis on individual bike inspection and more variable bike condition.

FAQ: Bicycle Blue Book vs. TPC

1. How does Bicycle Blue Book determine the value of a used bike?

Bicycle Blue Book uses a comprehensive database and a proprietary algorithm to determine the value of used bicycles. The valuation is based on several factors, including the bike's make, model, age, condition, and market trends. Users can input specific details about their bike on the Bicycle Blue Book website to get an estimated value. This tool is useful for sellers to price their bikes competitively or for buyers to ensure they are getting a fair deal. 

Bicycle Blue Blue can overvalue or undervalue certain bikes, and values can differ depending on location, so it’s always important to compare estimated values to local comps to get a full picture of a bike’s value. 

2. Can I buy or sell a bike directly through Bicycle Blue Book?

Yes, Bicycle Blue Book offers a platform for users to buy and sell bicycles. Sellers can list their bikes by providing detailed information and setting a price based on their valuation tool or their own expectations. Buyers can browse the listings, compare prices, and make purchases directly through the site. Bicycle Blue Book serves as a marketplace connecting buyers and sellers.

3. Why is TPC’s inventory more limited?

Because The Pro’s Closet specializes in Certified Pre-Owned bikes, we have to be more selective with the used bikes we buy and sell. There are high costs associated with having a dedicated team, facility, and parts on-hand to inspect and service used bikes to meet our Certified Pre-Owned standards. As a result, brand name, higher-end, and performance bikes that hold value better are the best starting place for our Certified Pre-Owned bikes.  

4. How does TPC add value vs. marketplaces & other retailers?

The Pro’s Closet offers an option for bike buyers who want to buy a used bike that has been inspected and serviced by professional mechanics to ensure it’s safe, reliable, and operating properly. We also back our bikes with a 30-day money back guarantee and risk-free returns. In our eyes, we sit between retailers who only sell new bikes and used bike marketplaces like Bicycle Blue Book, Pinkbike, Facebook, and Craigslist, giving bike buyers another option to find the perfect bike for their needs. 

[button]Shop Bikes[/button]